view extra/README @ 416:b4d0eafc5bfe

Fix code generation error in gcc6809 It turned out that under some circumstances, the gcc optimizer would select an instruction sequence that had the sense of a branch inverted. It seems this was due to a particular instruction pattern included in the machine description not being quite right with respect to how the condition codes were tracked. Removing that instruction pattern seems to fix things (subtraction with the arguments reversed). gcc seems to be smart enough to figure out how to reorganize code to work without this reversed sense subtraction and then do the right thing.
author William Astle <lost@l-w.ca>
date Thu, 24 Mar 2016 20:07:20 -0600
parents 8222f30a0781
children d7b7004b0883
line wrap: on
line source

These files are extra utility type scripts that can be used for various
purposes.

as

This is a sort of front-end script that makes lwasm look approximately like
gnu as which is useful for using lwasm as a backend to gcc.  You may need to
edit it to make it work fully.

ld

Similar to the "as" script above except for lwlink.


ar

Similar to the "as" script above except for lwar.

gcc6809lw-*.patch

These are patches to the main gcc source distribution for specific releases. 
The last number after the dash is a patch level for the specific patch. It
is worth noting that a patch for a particular minor version of GCC may work
with later minor versions in the same release sequence. That is, a patch
for 4.6.1 might work with 4.6.4. These are different to the official
gcc6809 releases in the following ways. First, all the source for as-6809
is removed. Also, the special "helper" makefile and directory is removed. 
Also, as of this writing, the latest "official" release was for gcc 4.3.4
which does not build on 64 bit linux.

In the event you have used the "official" gcc6809 with the default as6809
assembler that comes with it, you should be aware that while lwasm is mostly
compatible with it syntax wise, there are differences, particularly in
pseudo operations and source line syntax (most notably that you must have
whitespace preceeding assembler directives and instructions).  You will
likely not run into these unless you are using inline asm. Refer to the
lwtools documentation for the specific line format required by lwasm.

It is worth noting that neither gcc6809 nor lwtools comes with a standard C
library.

It is also worth noting that for many projects, it will be more flexible to
invoke lwlink directly rather than using the ld script or gcc as a front
end. See the lwtools documentation for details on using lwlink.

To use these scripts, you really need to understand how to build a gcc as a
cross compiler. The basics are that you put the as, ld, and ar scripts
whereever you plan to put your cross-development binaries. Then, when
building the cross compiler, you tell it where the scripts are.

Please note that the following recipe is an example only. If you are
planning to install multiple instances of gcc6809 for different targets, you
will most certainly need to modify the steps below. Providing a complete
understanding of building a gcc toolchain for cross compilation is well
beyond the scope of this document.

The following works for a single installation.

1. Install the ar, as, and ld scripts named m6809-unknown-{as,ar,ld} in a
directory in your path, say /usr/local/coco/bin/.

2. Make symbolic links to /bin/true for similarly named nm, objdump, ranlib,
and strip in the same directory  Some of these may not be necessary.

3. Unpack gcc and apply the gcc6809 patch. The gcc6809lw* patch file
in this directory is known to work with these instructions.

4. Make sure /usr/local/coco/bin is in your PATH

5. Make sure "." is NOT in your path or is at the END of PATH. If you have
gazillions of errors pop up compiling "gemodes.c", this is your problem.

6. In a directory (other than the gcc source, say "gcc-build" at the same
level as the main gcc directory, do (assuming gcc 4.3.4):

configure --enable-languages=c --target=m6809-unknown \
--program-prefix=m6809-unknown- --enable-obsolete \
--srcdir=../gcc-4.3.4 --disable-threads --disable-nls \
--disable-libssp --prefix=/usr/local/coco \
--with-as=/usr/local/coco/bin/m6809-unknown-as \
--with-ld=/usr/local/coco/bin/m6809-unknown-ld \
--with-ar=/usr/local/coco/bin/m6809-unknown-ar

NOTE: the last three are required to prevent selection of the wrong binutils
programs at runtime.

--with-sysroot might be useful if you have a C library involved.

7. Run "make". If errors appear, troubleshoot.

8. Run "make install". Note that you will have to have your PATH variable
for "root" set up correctly if your install prefix requires root privileges.

The above is WOMM certified. YMMV.

NOTES ABOUT SPECIFIC PATCHES
============================

gcc6809lw-4.6.4-2.patch

This patch essentially disables the "soft registers". These were causing
problems leading to compiler crashes. Removing the "t" constraint from
the instruction patterns allowed various issues to go away. It is not clear
if the original reasoning behind these soft registers is even valid any
more.

Also fixes a clearly incorrect comparision when determining if a constant
fits in 16 bits. For clarity, both the 8 bit and 16 bit comparisons are
replaced with straight forward range comparisons rather than the excessively
clever scheme that was present before.

gcc6809lw-4.6.4-3.patch

This is identical to the -2 version except it fixes the crt0.S file so it
builds properly with the --pragma=newsource option. In fact, it never did
build properly due to spaces in operands anyway. However, since gcc6809
doesn't come with a C library, it hasn't proved to be an issue.

Patches to provide a proper crt0.S file based around the actual way lwtools
works will be considered.

It's also worth noting that there are features inherited from previous
versions of gcc6809 that are not properly supported by these patches. In
particular, banking and "far calls" are not supported because there are no
targets supported by lwtools that do anything meaningful in the face of such
things. Patches to clean that up are also welcome. Either to do something
meaningful or to remove such features entirely.

gcc6809lw-4.6.4-4.patch

This is identical to the -3 version except it fixes a code generation bug
that showed up under optimization. It would result in the sense of a branch
following a subtraction being inverted for whatever reason. This change
seems to fix that.